Rome / The verdict
Rome or Florence?
Both, if your trip allows it: Italo lists the fastest Rome to Florence train at about 1h25, and travelers who know both cities most often recommend splitting the days. Choose Rome alone for ancient history and the Vatican, Florence alone for Renaissance art and a center you can cross on foot.
By The Real Traveler Experiences team. We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict.
The Rome story
Rome is not one city but several stacked on the same ground: imperial ruins, Renaissance churches and a working modern capital, with the Vatican inside it for good measure. The blockbuster sights earn their fame, trattorias feed you well once you step off the postcard streets, and the whole centre is an open-air museum crossed on foot.
The verdict in 30 seconds
Our pick: Both cities by train (runner-up: Rome)
Both, if your trip allows it: Italo lists the fastest Rome to Florence train at about 1h25, and travelers who know both cities most often recommend splitting the days. Choose Rome alone for ancient history and the Vatican, Florence alone for Renaissance art and a center you can cross on foot.
Go if
- You have 5 or more days to split between the two cities without feeling rushed
- You want both ancient Rome and Renaissance Florence rather than committing to one
- You are comfortable with one hotel change and a train ride in the middle of the trip
Skip if
- You have 3 days or fewer for Italy and need to commit to a single base
- You have a strong preference for ancient history and the Vatican or for Renaissance art, and would rather go deep on one city
- You cannot face a mid-trip transfer with luggage and a new hotel check-in
The options
Rome It depends
Travelers who want ancient history, the Vatican and a bigger, more varied city, and can only commit to one Italian city.
Good
- The Colosseum, the Forum, the Pantheon and the Vatican Museums give it more headline sights than Florence.
- Day trips such as Ostia Antica, Tivoli and Orvieto are within reach, per a couple who have been several times.
- Several travelers call it the stronger single choice for a first trip to Italy.
Watch out
- Its sights are spread out, so getting between clusters usually means the metro, a bus or a taxi.
- Major sights need timed tickets; a June traveler saw a very long Vatican ticket line from inside the timed-entry queue.
- Travelers describe its crowds as massive, with the Vatican, Colosseum, Trevi Fountain and Pantheon streets extremely congested.
Compare Rome pass pricespartner siteSee hotel options in Romepartner site
Florence It depends
Travelers who want Renaissance art, an easily walkable center and quick access to Tuscan day trips, and prefer a calmer pace.
Good
- Its historic center can be crossed on foot in about 20 minutes, per travelers who visit often.
- Travelers describe the art and the color of the city as the reason to go, with quieter museums such as San Marco worth seeking out.
- Tuscan towns and wine country make easy day trips.
Watch out
- A traveler who spent months there warns that visitors not drawn to Renaissance art can run out of things to do quickly.
- Travelers describe heavy crowds around the Duomo, the Ponte Vecchio and the Uffizi.
- A couple who drove found Florence's restricted traffic zone and parking costly and confusing.
See hotel options in Florencepartner site
Both cities by train Go
Travelers with 5 or more days who want ancient Rome and Renaissance Florence rather than committing to one.
Good
- Italo lists the fastest service at about 1h25, so the transfer takes half a day at most.
- Lets each city get the days travelers recommend, about 4 in Rome and 2 to 3 in Florence.
- Travelers who have done both say they would put both on the itinerary again.
Watch out
- Means checking out of one hotel and into another mid-trip, with luggage.
- Doubles the advance booking: timed tickets for both the Vatican Museums and the Uffizi.
- Only works with enough days; travelers call 5 days the tight minimum.
A one-night stop in each city Skip
Only travelers with no other option who would rather see a fraction of both cities than all of one.
Good
- Technically touches both Rome and Florence inside a short trip.
Watch out
- Travelers who plan Italy trips warn that moving hotels too often eats time in packing, check-out and check-in.
- A couple who know both cities say each deserves at least a full overnight, not a few rushed hours.
- A student who did Rome as a day trip from the coast would not necessarily recommend it.
| Criterion | Rome | Florence | Both cities by train | A one-night stop in each city |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Days travelers recommend | About 4 days | 2 to 3 days | 5 or more days total, about 4 in Rome and 2 to 3 in Florence | 1 night each, which travelers call too rushed |
| Signature museum ticket (official price) | Vatican Museums: 20 EUR standard, 10 EUR reduced | Uffizi Gallery: 25 EUR on the day, 29 EUR booked ahead | Both apply: 20 EUR Vatican Museums plus 25 to 29 EUR Uffizi Gallery | Both apply, with little time to use either |
| Getting between them | Not needed if staying only in Rome | Not needed if staying only in Florence | Italo fares from 14.90 EUR, about 1h25 | Same train, on a tight schedule |
| Walkability travelers report | Spread out; metro, bus or taxi between sight clusters | Center crossable on foot in about 20 minutes | Switches between the two styles partway through | Little time to learn either city |
| Crowds travelers report | Massive at the Vatican, Colosseum and Trevi Fountain | Packed around the Duomo, Ponte Vecchio and Uffizi; less dense overall | Each city's own pattern applies on its days | Arriving into crowds with no slack for queues |
What it costs
- Vatican Museums standard entry (Rome): €20 (reduced price 10 EUR; add 5 EUR for the online skip-the-line booking fee). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Colosseum, Roman Forum and Palatine Hill standard entry (Rome): €18 (reduced price 2 EUR for EU citizens aged 18 to 24. The official colosseo.it page could not be loaded on 2026-10-11 (connection timed out); price as last confirmed). Official source, checked Sep 2026.
- Trevi Fountain basin access ticket (Rome): €2 (required from 2 February 2026 to enter the basin; free for Rome residents, children under 5, and people with disabilities and their caregivers; applies daily 9am to 10pm). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Uffizi Gallery standard entry, on-site (Florence): €25 (29 EUR when bought before the day of entry). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Brunelleschi Pass, Florence Duomo dome climb plus museum, bell tower, baptistery and crypt (Florence): €30 (reduced price 12 EUR ages 7 to 14; the dome climb needs a timed slot). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Italo high-speed train, Rome to Florence one way, lowest advance fare: €14.90 (Italo lists the trip at 1 hour 25 minutes; fares start from this price). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
What travelers report
Based on 12 traveler reports (Nov 2024 to Sep 2026) and the official sources linked on this page. 1 was negative.
What people like
- Travelers who know both cities most often recommend splitting the trip, using the train between them.
- Rome's ancient sites and the Vatican are described as the strongest draw for a first trip to Italy.
- Florence's center is described as small enough to cross on foot in about 20 minutes.
- Travelers praise Florence's art and colors, with quieter museums such as San Marco a good escape from the queues.
What people complain about
- Travelers describe Florence's historic center packed with large tour groups, and the Uffizi crowded enough to drive one visitor to other rooms.
- Rome's crowds are called massive and sometimes overwhelming, with a very long Vatican Museums ticket line for those without timed entry.
- A day trip or a single rushed night in each city loses most of the time to the train and repacking, by travelers' accounts.
- Driving into either city is a hassle, with Florence's restricted traffic zone and expensive parking singled out.
How to do it right
- Match your trip length to the split travelers suggest: about 4 days in Rome and 2 to 3 in Florence for a week, or 3 and 2 if you only have 5 days.
- Book the Rome to Florence train online in advance; Italo lists its fastest service at about 1h25 with fares from 14.90 EUR.
- Book the Vatican Museums and the Uffizi ahead for whichever city is on the itinerary; a June traveler with a timed 8 AM Vatican entry walked past a very long ticket line.
- If only one city fits, match it to your priority: ancient history and the Vatican for Rome, Renaissance art and a walkable center for Florence.
- Give each city at least two nights if splitting the trip; travelers warn that a day trip or a single rushed night loses most of the time to transit and repacking.
- Plan Rome's Trevi Fountain visit around the 2 EUR basin ticket required since February 2026, and start early in both cities, since travelers report the worst crowds by late morning.
The trap to avoid
Treating a day trip or a one-night stop in each city as a real visit: travelers who have done it, and those who plan Italy trips for months at a time, say most of that time goes to the train, check-in and repacking rather than sightseeing.
What to do instead
Why this verdict
Most travelers in the log who know both cities land on the same answer: do both if the schedule allows it. Italo lists the fastest train at about 1h25, so treating the choice as strict either-or usually costs more than it saves. The couples and writers who have been to both several times describe Rome’s ancient sites and the Vatican as answering one kind of trip and Florence’s art and walkable center as answering another, and several say they would put both on the itinerary again.
That answer only holds with enough days. Travelers who put a number on it suggest about 4 days in Rome and 2 to 3 in Florence, with 3 and 2 as a tight minimum. The warnings are about compression: a planner who spends months in Italy cautions that changing hotels too often eats the trip, a couple advises against day-tripping between the cities, and a student who did Rome as a long day trip would not necessarily do it again.
Crowds are the main complaint in both cities, and the reports do not let either off. In Florence, travelers describe tour groups filling the historic center in September and an Uffizi so crowded in late October that one visitor fled to quieter rooms. In Rome, travelers call the crowds massive, and a June visitor saw a very long Vatican ticket line from the timed-entry queue. That same visitor found Florence less dense overall, which matches the picture of a smaller city with concentrated hot spots.
When a trip only has room for one city, the split tracks priority rather than one city beating the other. Several travelers send first-timers to Rome for its scale and headline sights; one who has visited both many times picks Florence as the gentler start. A traveler who spent months in Florence adds a useful caution: visitors not drawn to Renaissance art may run out of things to do there faster than in Rome.
Timing and tickets
Book timed entry for the Vatican Museums and the Uffizi, and book the train early, since Italo’s fares start at 14.90 EUR and rise closer to the date. In Rome, the Trevi Fountain basin has required a 2 EUR ticket since February 2026.
Book or check times
Vatican Museums tickets and pricesColosseum, Forum and Palatine ticketsUffizi Gallery ticketsFlorence Duomo ticketsItalo Rome to Florence train tickets
We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict. How this works
Compare Rome pass pricespartner siteSee hotel options in Romepartner siteSee hotel options in Florencepartner site
Questions
How long does the train between Rome and Florence take?
Italo's own site lists the fastest Rome to Florence service at 1 hour 25 minutes, with fares from 14.90 EUR that rise closer to the travel date.
How many days do you need in each city?
Travelers who know both put Rome at about 4 days and Florence at 2 to 3, so a combined trip works best with 5 or more days total. One suggests 3 in Rome and 2 in Florence if 5 days is all you have.
Is Florence more walkable than Rome?
Yes, by travelers' accounts: one couple who visit often say you can walk across Florence's historic center in about 20 minutes, while Rome's sights spread out and usually need the metro, a bus or a taxi between clusters.
Which city is better for a first trip to Italy?
Reports split. Several travelers send first-timers to Rome for the Colosseum, the Vatican and the scale of it, while one who has visited both many times says Florence is the better first pick because it is smaller and less overwhelming. Most of them would rather you see both.
Is Florence crowded?
Its top sights are. Travelers describe tour groups packing the historic center in September, a crowded Uffizi in late October and lines at the Duomo, though a June visitor found Florence less dense overall than Rome.
Can you day-trip to Florence from Rome instead of staying overnight?
Travelers advise against it. A couple who know both cities say round-trip travel eats the day and each city deserves at least an overnight, and a student who did Rome as a day trip would not necessarily recommend it.
Pack for it
Gear verdicts from our sister site, Real Buyer Experiences: