Reykjavik / The verdict
Reykjavik or Oslo?
Reykjavik for a landscape-first trip, Oslo for a city stay: the reports in the log put Reykjavik travelers on Golden Circle and South Coast day trips and thermal pools, and Oslo travelers in museums, saunas and cafes. Posters say nonstop flights link the two, so combining them is simple.
By The Real Traveler Experiences team. We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict.
The Reykjavik story
Reykjavik is the smallest-feeling capital in Europe: colorful tin-roofed houses, the rocket-church silhouette of Hallgrimskirkja, the Harpa concert hall on the waterfront, and a 101 downtown you can cross on foot in twenty minutes. It works as a base camp rather than a museum city, and the famous Iceland is mostly outside it, which the city itself seems to know.
The verdict in 30 seconds
Our pick: Reykjavik (runner-up: Oslo)
Reykjavik for a landscape-first trip, Oslo for a city stay: the reports in the log put Reykjavik travelers on Golden Circle and South Coast day trips and thermal pools, and Oslo travelers in museums, saunas and cafes. Posters say nonstop flights link the two, so combining them is simple.
Go if
- You want a landscape-first trip: waterfalls, lava fields and black sand beaches by rental car from a Reykjavik base
- You want a city stay built on museums, saunas and cafes, with a fjord inside the city
- You can add a second capital: posters say nonstop flights link Keflavik and Oslo
Skip if
- You plan no rental car or tours in Iceland: the family in the log called a car non-negotiable for the landscapes
- You want western Norway's fjord scenery: the family in the log based four nights in Bergen for that, not in Oslo
- You dislike rain: that family reported rain almost the entire time in Reykjavik
The options
Reykjavik Go
Landscape-first travelers who want a city base for day trips and public thermal pools.
Good
- A family based four nights in a Reykjavik Airbnb and covered the Golden Circle, South Coast waterfalls, black sand beaches and puffins by rental car.
- A blogger who visited twice calls the downtown quirky and welcoming, worth a few days on its own, with a walking tour, museums and cafes.
- The public thermal pools are a budget alternative to the big lagoons, per that blogger, and a layover traveler made them the first stop.
Watch out
- The same blogger names cost as the main drawback and calls accommodation expensive.
- A family reported rain almost the entire time and said a rental car is non-negotiable for the landscapes.
- A layover traveler found Reykjavik overcast in the 50s F in mid-August.
Visit Reykjavik, the official tourism siteStraeto bus faresSee Reykjavik hotelspartner site
Oslo It depends
City-first travelers who want museums, saunas and cafes with fjord water inside the city.
Good
- A winter vlogger spent three days on a fjord sauna with an ice plunge, the National Museum, the Nobel Peace Center and the Folk Museum village.
- A traveler's full Oslo day covered a ramen lunch and an Oslofjord island in sunny 80F weather.
- Coffee and pastry stops fill the gaps between sights, per the winter vlog.
Watch out
- In winter the vlogger's days leaned on indoor stops, with foggy streets between them.
- Official fares are 46 NOK for a zone 1 ticket and 276 NOK one way on the airport express, so short stays still add up.
Visit Oslo, the official tourism siteRuter tickets and faresSee Oslo hotelspartner site
Both cities in one trip Go
Travelers who want the landscape base and the city stay in one itinerary.
Good
- A forum traveler spent a three-day Reykjavik layover on pools and hot dogs, then flew on to Oslo for a full day.
- Posters say SAS and Icelandair both fly nonstop between Keflavik and Oslo, and that Icelandair's free stopovers make it easy.
- The contrast is wide: overcast 50s F in Reykjavik and sunny 80F in Oslo within days, in that layover report.
Watch out
- The one two-city report gave Reykjavik three days and Oslo one, which is tight for either.
- Two airport legs add up: Flybus is 3,999 ISK to the BSI terminal and the Oslo airport express is 276 NOK one way.
| Criterion | Reykjavik | Oslo | Both cities in one trip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signature strength | Golden Circle and South Coast day trips, public thermal pools | National Museum, Nobel Peace Center, fjord sauna | A landscape base plus a city stay |
| Nature access reported | Rental car day trips to waterfalls, lava fields and black sand beaches | A fjord sauna and an Oslofjord island inside the city | Both, in one trip |
| City feel reported | Quirky, welcoming, walkable with a walking tour | Ramen lunches, cafes and museums | Both feels, three days against one in the report |
| Weather reported | Rain almost the entire time (family); overcast 50s F in August (layover) | Sunny 80F in August; foggy winter streets | Pack for both |
| Local fare, official | 690 ISK bus single, checked 2026-10-07 | 46 NOK zone 1 single, checked 2026-10-07 | Both fares apply |
| Airport to city, official | Flybus 3,999 ISK adult to BSI terminal | Airport express 276 NOK adult one way | Both legs apply |
| Getting between them | Nonstop flights to Oslo, per posters | Nonstop flights to Keflavik, per posters | SAS and Icelandair nonstop; Icelandair stopovers free, per posters |
What it costs
- Straeto capital-area bus, adult single fare (Reykjavik): kr 690 (Contactless payment is the same price). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Ruter zone 1 single ticket, adult (Oslo): kr 46 (covers metro, trams, buses and local ferries inside zone 1). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Flybus airport coach, Keflavik Airport to BSI Bus Terminal, adult: kr 3999 (Hotel drop-off costs 5,299 ISK). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Flytoget airport express, adult one way (Oslo): kr 276 (Oslo Airport to Oslo Central Station). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
What travelers report
Based on 5 traveler reports (Feb 2025 to Oct 2025) and the official sources linked on this page. 0 were negative.
What people like
- A blogger who has visited Reykjavik twice calls it a quirky, welcoming city that is worth a few days on its own.
- A family based in Reykjavik found the Golden Circle and South Coast landscapes unreal despite the rain.
- A layover traveler called Reykjavik's public geothermal pools awesome and made them the first stop.
- A winter Oslo vlogger packed three days with a fjord sauna, museums and pastries.
What people complain about
- A blogger names cost as Reykjavik's main drawback and calls accommodation expensive.
- A family reported rain almost the entire time in Reykjavik and called a rental car non-negotiable.
- A layover traveler found Reykjavik overcast in the 50s F in mid-August, against sunny 80F in Oslo days later.
How to do it right
- Pick Reykjavik when the trip is the landscape: one family based four nights in a Reykjavik Airbnb and drove the Golden Circle and South Coast in a rental car.
- Pick Oslo when the city is the trip: a winter vlogger filled three days with a fjord sauna, the National Museum, the Nobel Peace Center and the Folk Museum village.
- Do both when you can: a layover traveler spent three days in Reykjavik, then a full day in Oslo, and posters say SAS and Icelandair fly nonstop between the two.
- Budget the transit: official fares checked 2026-10-07 are 690 ISK for a Reykjavik bus single, 46 NOK for an Oslo zone 1 ticket, 3,999 ISK for Flybus and 276 NOK one way on the Oslo airport express.
- Pack a rain layer for Reykjavik: the family in the log reported rain almost the entire time.
The trap to avoid
Assuming Reykjavik alone delivers the landscapes. The family in the log needed a rental car for the Golden Circle and South Coast and met rain almost the entire time, so a stay confined to downtown misses most of what they came for. Oslo is the opposite: its reports center on city stops, and the family that wanted Norway's fjord scenery based in Bergen.
What to do instead
Why this pick
This is a lean, not a landslide: Reykjavik wins for a landscape-first trip. A family spent four nights in a Reykjavik Airbnb, drove the Golden Circle and South Coast in a rental car they called non-negotiable, and found the black sand beaches, lava fields and puffins unreal even though it rained almost the entire time. A blogger who has visited twice adds that the downtown is quirky and welcoming, worth a few days on its own, and that the public thermal pools are a budget alternative to the big lagoons.
Oslo is the pick when the city is the trip. A winter vlogger spent three days there on a fjord sauna with an ice plunge, the National Museum, the Nobel Peace Center, the Folk Museum village and a lot of coffee and pastries. A forum traveler’s full Oslo day centered on a ramen lunch in Grunerlokka and an Oslofjord island, in sunny 80F weather.
Cost cuts against Reykjavik more clearly in the log: the blogger names it as the main drawback and calls accommodation expensive. Official local fares are 690 ISK for a Reykjavik bus single and 46 NOK for an Oslo zone 1 ticket, checked 2026-10-07.
Planning the split
You can do both. A forum traveler spent a three-day Reykjavik layover on the pools and hot dogs, then flew to Oslo for a full day, and posters in another thread say SAS and Icelandair both fly nonstop between Keflavik and Oslo, with Icelandair’s free stopovers making the pairing easy. The airport legs add up twice: Flybus is 3,999 ISK for an adult to the BSI terminal and the Oslo airport express is 276 NOK one way. Pack a rain layer for Reykjavik; the same layover traveler found it overcast in the 50s F while Oslo was sunny at 80F days later.
Book or check times
Visit Reykjavik, the official tourism siteVisit Oslo, the official tourism siteIcelandair stopover programStraeto bus faresRuter tickets and fares
We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict. How this works
See Reykjavik hotelspartner siteSee Oslo hotelspartner site
Questions
Which is cheaper, Reykjavik or Oslo?
Official local fares are 690 ISK for a Reykjavik bus single and 46 NOK for an Oslo zone 1 ticket, checked 2026-10-07. A blogger who visited Reykjavik twice names cost as its main drawback and calls accommodation expensive.
Can you do Reykjavik and Oslo in one trip?
Yes. A forum traveler spent a three-day Reykjavik layover on the pools, then flew to Oslo for a full day, and posters say SAS and Icelandair both fly nonstop between Keflavik and Oslo, with Icelandair's free stopovers making the pairing easy.
How many days do you need in each?
The reports vary: a family spent four nights in Reykjavik for day trips, a layover traveler spent three days there and one in Oslo, and a winter vlogger spent three days in Oslo.
Do you need a car in Reykjavik?
For the Golden Circle and South Coast, one family called a rental car non-negotiable. In the city, a blogger covered the history with a walking tour and used the public thermal pools.
What is Oslo like in winter?
A winter vlog filled three days with a fjord sauna and ice plunge, the National Museum, the Nobel Peace Center, the Folk Museum village, pastries and coffee, with foggy streets between stops.
Is Reykjavik worth visiting as a city?
A blogger who has visited twice says yes: a quirky, welcoming downtown worth a few days on its own, with a walking tour, museums and public thermal pools, though she names cost as the drawback.
Pack for it
Gear verdicts from our sister site, Real Buyer Experiences: