Malta / The verdict
Malta or Sicily: which to visit?
For most trips of a week or less, Malta is the better call: one small island, English as an official language, buses and Bolt reaching everything. Sicily is the bigger, foodier, deeper destination, but reports are blunt that it wants 10 to 14 days and a rental car, not a long weekend.
By The Real Traveler Experiences team. We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict.
The Malta story
Malta packs an absurd amount into 316 square kilometres: a baroque capital built by crusading knights, the Barrakka panorama over the Grand Harbour, St John's co-cathedral's barrel vault and 400-tomb inlaid floor, temples older than the pyramids at the Hypogeum, Mdina's free walled ramparts, and lagoon water warm enough to swim from April to October. English is an official language, the ferries are cheap, and a day on Gozo or the Blue Lagoon is the island's deep breath.
The verdict in 30 seconds
Our pick: Malta (runner-up: Sicily)
For most trips of a week or less, Malta is the better call: one small island, English as an official language, buses and Bolt reaching everything. Sicily is the bigger, foodier, deeper destination, but reports are blunt that it wants 10 to 14 days and a rental car, not a long weekend.
Go if
- Travelers with about a week deciding between an easy small island and a vast layered one
- First-time Mediterranean visitors weighing English-language ease against Italian scale
- Planners tempted to do both on one trip by ferry or short flight
Skip if
- You have more than two weeks and a driving appetite; reports then favour Sicily outright
- You already know the trip is diving-led or Etna-led; the verdicts below only break ties
The options
Malta Go
Trips of about a week or less, first-time Mediterranean visitors, and anyone who wants the easy option: English everywhere, no car, one base
Good
- The whole island's headline list fits in 4 to 7 days from one base
- English is an official language; buses, ferries and cheap Bolt rides remove the car question
- Valletta, Mdina, temples older than the pyramids and the Blue Lagoon deliver real depth per square kilometre
Watch out
- Sandy beaches are scarce; most swimming is off rock and the shoreline is built up
- The Sliema to St Julian's corridor is crowded and construction-heavy in season
- A week exhausts it; slow travelers run out of new ground
See hotel options across Maltapartner site
Sicily Go
Trips of ten days and up, food-first travelers, and anyone after Greek temples, baroque towns, Etna and sandy beaches
Good
- Decisively foodier: markets, arancini, cannoli, Etna wines and street-food culture
- Seven UNESCO sites, an active volcano, and cities with different characters
- Cheaper beds and meals once outside the Taormina-grade hotspots
Watch out
- Its size is the tax: Palermo to Syracuse is three hours and a week covers one corner
- A rental car is near-essential, and reports warn city driving plus rural Italian take nerve
- Under a week it frustrates; travelers describe barely scratching it
See hotel options across Sicilypartner site
Malta and Sicily on one trip Go
Trips of ten days or more, where a week-plus in Sicily pairs naturally with three or four days in Malta
Good
- The Pozzallo catamaran takes about 1 hour 45 minutes and the Ragusa ferry now runs four days a week
- Ryanair covers Malta to Catania in about 40 minutes, making open-jaw itineraries easy
- Reports that combined them call the pairing complementary: Italy's depth plus Malta's ease
Watch out
- Under ten days the transit hours eat both; forums advise picking one
- Two different gears: a car-based Sicily leg followed by Malta's no-car pace
- Ferry weather days can shuffle plans; build slack around the crossing
Sicily as a day trip from Malta Skip
Nobody who wants Sicily itself; only travelers content with a guided taste of Syracuse or Etna between long transits
Good
- The catamaran makes a taste physically possible in one long day
- Guided day tours cover transport, so no logistics burden
Watch out
- Dawn-to-midnight transit for a few hours on shore; reports call it exhausting
- Pozzallo port is not the Sicily anyone means; everything worthwhile sits beyond
- It scratches the itch without satisfying it; an overnight or a proper Sicily trip beats it
| Criterion | Malta | Sicily | Malta and Sicily on one trip | Sicily as a day trip from Malta |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Time the trip needs | 4 to 7 days covers the headline list | 10 to 14 days minimum, and only a slice of it | 10 to 12 days and up, split roughly 7 to 9 plus 3 or 4 | A 16-plus-hour round trip for a few hours ashore |
| Getting around | Buses, ferries and Bolt; no car, everything in English | A rental car is near-essential; Italian rules outside hotspots | A car on the Sicily leg, none needed on the Malta leg | Coach-bound after the ferry; no independent exploring |
| Food and drink | Good and Italian-influenced: rabbit stew, ftira, pastizzi | World-class: markets, arancini, cannoli, Etna wines | Both cuisines, across two currencies-free stops | A rushed lunch at best |
| Headline sights | Valletta, Mdina, megalithic temples, Blue Lagoon | Etna, Valley of the Temples, Taormina, Palermo, Syracuse | The full union of both lists | One snapshot, usually Syracuse or an Etna drive-by |
| Beaches | Rocky coves and a few sandy bays; famously clear water | The Mediterranean's broadest sandy variety | Both | Effectively none on a day-trip clock |
| Daily spend reported | Firmer resort-strip prices, but no car bill on a short stay | Cheaper food and stays off the hotspots, plus a rental car to pay for | The sum of both, minus duplication | Excursion pricing for transit, not Sicily |
What it costs
- Virtu Ferries catamaran, Valletta to Pozzallo, adult return (more than one day): €100 (Crossing is about 1 hour 45 minutes, roughly twice daily; seasonal promotions have run as low as EUR 69 in September and EUR 50 at winter rates). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Malta bus single fare (including X4 airport to Valletta), winter: €2 (winter fare 18 October 2026 to 12 June 2027; EUR 2.50 in summer; valid 2 hours with transfers). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Malta bus, 12 single day journeys: €19 (shareable, valid six months from first use, free transfers within two hours). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
What travelers report
Based on 13 traveler reports (Dec 2024 to Jun 2026) and the official sources linked on this page. 0 were negative.
What people like
- Malta packs three UNESCO sites, Valletta, Mdina and the Blue Lagoon into an island you cross in 40 minutes (6 of 13 reports)
- Sicily's food, Greek temples, Etna and city variety earn it the deeper-trip win (7 reports)
- English is an official language in Malta and navigation needs no car, which reports call the easiest Mediterranean trip going (5 reports)
- The two pair well: catamaran and 40-minute flights make a combined trip routine at two weeks (4 reports)
- Malta's direct reach keeps improving, with the first US carrier flight landing in June 2026 (1 report)
What people complain about
- Sicily in under 10 days means spending the trip in a car and still missing most of it (4 reports)
- Malta's beaches are mostly rock; sandy-shore seekers prefer Sicily's variety (4 reports)
- The Sicily day trip from Malta is a dawn-to-midnight exercise reports describe as exhausting (3 reports)
- Malta's resort strip reads as crowded and construction-heavy in season (2 reports)
How to do it right
- Match the island to the trip length before anything else: reports put Malta's full headline list inside 4 to 7 days, while Sicily needs a chosen slice and at least 10 days
- Decide on driving: Malta runs on buses, ferries and cheap Bolt rides in English; Sicily expects a rental car, city driving nerve and Italian outside the hotspots
- Pick Sicily when the trip is food, volcano and Greek-temple led, or when you have two weeks and patience for distances
- Pick Malta when the trip is a short break, a first Mediterranean visit, or a no-car stay where every day should be simple
- Combining works well from 10 or 12 days up: the Pozzallo catamaran takes about 1 hour 45 minutes, a second ferry to Ragusa runs four days a week, and Ryanair flies Malta to Catania in about 40 minutes
- Skip the Sicily day trip entirely unless you accept an organized excursion; reports describe dawn-to-midnight transit for a few hours on shore
The trap to avoid
Booking Sicily for five days and spending it in a car. Every report agrees Sicily's scale is the appeal and the trap: Palermo to Syracuse is three hours of driving, and a week covers one corner of the island, which is precisely the scenario where Malta beats it.
What to do instead
Why this pick
Malta for a trip of about a week or less, Sicily once you have ten days and a car. Reports answer this question the same way almost every time: it is a duration question in disguise. Under about a week, Malta wins cleanly. Travelers who explored both describe Malta as coverable in a week from one base, while Sicily demands that you choose a slice. English is an official language in Malta, and buses, ferries and ride-hailing mean visitors there rarely rent a car; one trip report covered the island without one, with rides averaging about EUR 14.
Sicily is the bigger, foodier, deeper destination, and the reports that prefer it are emphatic about food, Greek temples, Etna, beaches and city variety. One both-visited comparison names Sicily its personal favorite for breadth and gastronomy, yet still recommends Malta for stays of five to seven days. Another traveler who did Sicily then Malta calls Malta convenient and Sicily memorable. The catch is scale: it is 81 times Malta’s size, a rental car is close to essential, and forum veterans who spent a month there still call it unfinished. Under ten days, the forum advice in the log is to pick fewer places and slow down, which is the scenario where Malta beats it.
So the pick goes to Malta for the trip most people are planning, and Sicily is the runner-up that wins outright once you have ten days, wheels and an appetite. Both on one trip is a sound plan from about ten days up: the catamaran crossing takes about 1 hour 45 minutes, a second ferry to Ragusa now runs four days a week according to local coverage, and the Malta to Catania flight takes about 40 minutes. One forum reply sketches 10 days in Sicily plus three or four in Malta via the Pozzallo ferry.
Timing and tickets
On Malta, the bus is the default. Malta Public Transport lists a winter single fare of EUR 2.00 from 18 October 2026 to 12 June 2027 and EUR 2.50 in summer, valid two hours with transfers, and the X4 runs from the airport to Valletta on the same fare. A bundle of 12 single journeys costs EUR 19, can be shared and stays valid for six months, which suits a couple on a week-long stay.
Between the islands, the operator lists an adult return on the catamaran from Valletta to Pozzallo at EUR 100 for trips longer than a day, with seasonal promotions below that. If Sicily is the longer leg, the flight to Catania is the quicker link.
On a combined trip, check the ferry timetable before fixing dates, since the crossing sets the hinge of the itinerary.
The version to skip
What reports do not recommend is Sicily in a day. The ferry gets you there in about 1 hour 45 minutes, but Pozzallo port is not the Sicily anyone means, and the do-it-yourself version runs dawn to midnight for a few hours ashore. Guided day tours exist, and the review in the log calls the Syracuse, Etna and Taormina sweep convenient but rushed. If Sicily matters enough to cross, give it nights.
Book or check times
Virtu Ferries fares and scheduleMalta Public Transport faresVisit Malta, official tourism site
We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict. How this works
See hotel options across Maltapartner siteSee hotel options across Sicilypartner site
Questions
Is Malta or Sicily better for a week?
Malta, per the reports: its sights fit inside 4 to 7 days without a car. Sicily at one week means choosing east or west and a rental car; travelers who tried a week of Sicily describe barely scratching it.
Is Sicily worth a day trip from Malta?
Only as an organized excursion, and even then reports call it rushed. The catamaran is about 1 hour 45 minutes each way, Pozzallo town itself is not the draw, and do-it-yourself versions run dawn to midnight for a few hours on the island. A night or three is the straightforward version.
Is Malta cheaper than Sicily?
Close, with a tilt each way. Reports find Sicily cheaper for food and stays away from the Taormina-grade hotspots, while Malta is easier to keep on budget on a short trip because a car never enters the bill. Both sit well under northern-European prices.
Which has better food, Malta or Sicily?
Sicily, decisively in the comparisons: arancini, cannoli, Etna wines and the Palermo and Catania street markets are world-class. Maltese food, rabbit stew, ftira and pastizzi, is good and heavily Italian-influenced rather than a draw in itself.
Do you need a car in Malta or Sicily?
Malta: no. Buses, two small ferries and Bolt cover everything, and one trip report averaged EUR 14 per Bolt ride island-wide. Sicily: effectively yes, especially for villages, beaches and Etna; reports warn driving there takes nerve and Italian helps.
How do you get between Malta and Sicily?
Three ways. The Virtu Ferries catamaran runs Valletta to Pozzallo in about 1 hour 45 minutes at EUR 100 standard return, with seasonal offers from EUR 50 to 69. The new Ragusa Xpress ferry runs about two hours, four days a week. Ryanair flies Malta to Catania in about 40 minutes.
Pack for it
Gear verdicts from our sister site, Real Buyer Experiences: