Florence / The verdict
Florence or Venice?
Do both if you have time: Florence and Venice are about 2 hours apart on Italo's high-speed line, and the writers in the log favor Florence for value and art and Venice for atmosphere. If you can only pick one, the log leans toward Florence.
By The Real Traveler Experiences team. We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict.
The Florence story
Florence is the Renaissance kept walkable: the Duomo, the Uffizi, Michelangelo's David and the Ponte Vecchio all inside a centre you can cross in twenty minutes, with Tuscan wine country at the doorstep. The scale is the charm, heavyweight art and architecture without heavyweight distances, plus the food, wine bars and aperitivo culture to fill the evenings.
The verdict in 30 seconds
Our pick: Both cities by train (runner-up: Florence)
Do both if you have time: Florence and Venice are about 2 hours apart on Italo's high-speed line, and the writers in the log favor Florence for value and art and Venice for atmosphere. If you can only pick one, the log leans toward Florence.
Go if
- You have about five days and can split them between the two cities, as one writer suggests with three days in Florence and two in Venice
- You want Florence's art and food plus Venice's canals and quiet early-morning and late-night hours
- You are happy to book timed entry ahead for the Uffizi Gallery and the Doge's Palace
Skip if
- You have only two days or fewer and need to commit to one city
- You are weighing a one-day stop in the other city, since a day visitor to Venice misses the quiet early and late hours writers describe
- You want to avoid Venice's day-tripper fee on its set 2026 dates, which applies to visitors without an overnight stay
The options
Florence It depends
Travelers who want art, food and lower prices, and can commit to one city.
Good
- Writers describe it as the better value, with more attractions and better restaurants.
- One writer says it handles its crowds better than Venice.
- Easy day trips, according to one writer.
Watch out
- News coverage reports an outdoor dining ban on about 50 historic-center streets.
- One writer says Florence has its own over-tourism.
- It does not have Venice's canals.
See Florence hotel optionspartner site
Venice It depends
Travelers who want canals and atmosphere and can stay overnight, plan for crowds and budget for higher prices.
Good
- A writer who has visited three times says it is worth the trip.
- One writer describes quiet early mornings and nights.
- One writer suggests starting a multi-city trip here for easier airport access.
Watch out
- Writers describe higher prices and heavy crowds, including cruise-ship crowds.
- Seasonal flooding in the shoulder season narrows the best time to go, according to one writer.
- A day-tripper fee applies on set 2026 dates for visitors without an overnight stay, according to news coverage.
See Venice hotel optionspartner site
Both cities by train Go
Travelers with about five days who want Florence's art and food plus Venice's atmosphere.
Good
- Italo's official page lists the trip at 2 hours with fares from 18.90 EUR.
- Writers in the log suggest covering both cities on one Italy trip.
- An overnight stay in Venice avoids the day-tripper fee, according to news coverage.
Watch out
- You book timed entry at sights in both cities.
- Both cities' costs add up, and Venice runs higher.
- It needs enough days; the writer who suggests three plus two days is planning about five.
A rushed day trip to the other city Skip
Only travelers with no other option who would rather see part of both cities than all of one.
Good
- Adds a second city to a trip built around the first.
Watch out
- A day visitor to Venice misses the quiet early mornings and nights one writer describes.
- The Venice day-tripper fee applies on set 2026 dates, according to news coverage.
- The log has no report of a one-day trip that worked well.
| Criterion | Florence | Venice | Both cities by train | A rushed day trip to the other city |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Official price of the signature sight | Uffizi Gallery 25 EUR on the day, 29 EUR before the date | Doge's Palace 35 EUR, or 30 EUR online at least 30 days ahead | Both apply: one Florence sight plus one Venice sight | Both apply, with less time to use either ticket |
| Getting there by train | Not needed if staying only in Florence | Not needed if staying only in Venice | Italo lists 2 hours, fares from 18.90 EUR | Same train, used on a single day |
| Daily cost writers describe | Lower: described as cheaper and better value for dining | Higher: described as pricier, with high hotel prices | Both cities' cost levels apply across the trip | Both apply, with less time to use any savings |
| 2026 changes in the news | Outdoor dining structures banned on about 50 historic-center streets | Day-tripper fee on set spring and summer dates, overnight guests exempt | Both cities' changes apply across the trip | Venice fee applies to a day visitor on set dates |
| Crowds writers describe | Crowded, but one writer says Florence handles it better | Heavy crowds, including cruise-ship crowds | Both apply, on separate days | Same crowds, with no early or late hours in the city |
What it costs
- Uffizi Gallery standard entry, purchased on the day: €25 (29 EUR when purchased before the date of entry). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Doge's Palace standard entry, includes the St Mark's Square museums: €35 (30 EUR online when booked at least 30 days before the visit). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- St Mark's Basilica entry alone: €10 (20 EUR with the Pala d'Oro; see the official price page for other combinations). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
- Italo train, Florence to Venice, one way, lowest listed fare: €18.90 (the official page lists a trip duration of 2 hours and fares from 18.90 EUR). Official source, checked Oct 2026.
What travelers report
Based on 8 traveler reports (Apr 2025 to Aug 2026) and the official sources linked on this page. 3 were negative.
What people like
- Writers favor Florence for art, food and value, and one says it handles its crowds better than Venice.
- One writer who stayed several days in Venice describes quiet early mornings and nights.
- A writer who has visited Venice three times says it is worth the trip, and suggests riding the number 1 vaporetto at dusk in place of a gondola.
What people complain about
- Writers describe Venice as pricier and more crowded, with cruise-ship crowds and seasonal flooding in the shoulder season.
- News coverage reports Venice's day-tripper access fee on set 2026 dates for visitors without an overnight stay.
- News coverage reports Florence removing outdoor dining structures on about 50 historic-center streets after resident complaints.
How to do it right
- Match the split to your priority: more days in Florence for art, food and value, more in Venice for canals and atmosphere. One writer suggests three days in Florence and two in Venice.
- Book the Florence to Venice train ahead of time. Italo's official page lists the trip at 2 hours, with fares from 18.90 EUR.
- Book the Uffizi Gallery and the Doge's Palace on their official sites. The Uffizi is 25 EUR on the day and 29 EUR when bought before the date, and the Doge's Palace is 30 EUR online when booked at least 30 days ahead.
- Check St Mark's Basilica prices on its official ticket site before you go; entry alone is listed at 10 EUR.
- If Venice would be a day stop rather than an overnight stay, check the day-tripper fee dates first. News coverage describes set spring and summer dates in 2026, with a higher fee for late bookings and overnight guests exempt.
- If you plan to eat in Florence's historic center, expect fewer outdoor tables: news coverage reports a ban on outdoor dining structures on about 50 streets.
The trap to avoid
Treating Venice as a single rushed day stop. One writer who stayed several days describes the quiet early mornings and nights, hours a day visitor mostly misses, and day visitors face the access fee on set dates.
What to do instead
Why this verdict
The writers in the log mostly agree on how the two cities differ. Florence comes out ahead on value, art and food, and one writer says it handles its crowds better. Venice is described as pricier and more crowded, hurt by cruise-ship crowds and seasonal flooding, yet a writer who has been three times calls it worth the trip, and another describes quiet early mornings and nights during a multi-day stay.
That points to doing both when you have the time, rather than choosing one. The only suggested split in the log is three days in Florence and two in Venice, so about five days. Italo’s official page lists the train between the two at 2 hours, with fares from 18.90 EUR. If you can only choose one city, the log leans toward Florence for most travelers.
A rushed day in the other city is the option to skip. The log has no report of a one-day trip that worked well. A day visitor misses the quiet hours one writer describes in Venice, and news coverage reports a day-tripper fee on set spring and summer dates in 2026, with overnight guests exempt. Florence has its own 2026 change, with news coverage reporting an outdoor dining ban on about 50 historic-center streets.
Timing and tickets
Book the Uffizi Gallery and the Doge’s Palace on their official sites. The Uffizi lists 25 EUR on the day and 29 EUR before the date, and the Doge’s Palace lists 30 EUR online when booked at least 30 days ahead. Check St Mark’s Basilica prices on its official ticket site. Book the Florence to Venice train ahead of time as well, since Italo’s lowest listed fare is from 18.90 EUR. If Venice would be a day stop rather than an overnight stay, check the day-tripper fee dates first.
Book or check times
Uffizi Gallery ticketsDoge's Palace ticketsSt Mark's Basilica ticketsFlorence to Venice train tickets
We earn a commission if you book through our links. It never changes a verdict. How this works
See Florence hotel optionspartner siteSee Venice hotel optionspartner site
Questions
How long does the train between Florence and Venice take?
Italo's official page lists the trip at 2 hours, with fares from 18.90 EUR.
Which city is cheaper?
Writers in the log describe Florence as the better value. One says Florence is cheaper, and another says it edges ahead on budget dining, while describing Venice as pricier.
Do I need to book tickets ahead for the main sights?
The Uffizi sells tickets at 25 EUR on the day and 29 EUR before the date, and the Doge's Palace lists 30 EUR online when booked at least 30 days ahead, against 35 EUR at the standard price.
Is Venice's day-tripper fee something to plan around?
Only for a visit without an overnight stay. News coverage describes set spring and summer dates in 2026, with a higher fee for late bookings and overnight guests exempt.
How many days does each city need?
One writer in the log suggests three days in Florence and two in Venice. Another says to see Venice before Florence on a multi-city trip, for easier airport access.
Is a one-day stop in the other city worth it?
The log has no report of a one-day trip that worked well. One writer saw Venice for a single day of a three-day stay, and another describes its best hours as early morning and night.
Pack for it
Gear verdicts from our sister site, Real Buyer Experiences: